And thus my series of Doctor Who reviews concludes with a novel featuring what is still my favourite Doctor.
Where we're at
Set during Season 30/Series 4, this features the Tenth Doctor and Donna.
Conclusion
A good novel, but not one of my personal favourites.
8/10
The plot
The Doctor and Donna head for Calcutta in 1937... and end up arriving ten years later, at a turbulent time in India's history (i.e. just before independence). People are going missing and strange white 'half-made' men are appearing. Teaming up with Gandhi, the time travellers investigate.
What works
What doesn't- Gandhi is a bit of an unusual choice for a 'celebrity historical', but it works here. I get the impression of what was a very good man, whose untimely death arguably made things worse for South Asia in the longer term. His goodness actually plays a key role in the plot.
- The two regulars are portrayed very well; the Tenth Doctor in particular.
- Some good gadgets feature in this and the sonic screwdriver also gets some nice usage here, although some stuff about how it works is contradicted by later TV episodes.
- The big twist is good... but looking at other reviews, I'm inclined to agree it's a bit humdrum and it would have been better with a double twist.
- I'd have personally liked to come out of this book with a bit further knowledge of the real events that took place around Indian and Pakistani independence.
Conclusion
A good novel, but not one of my personal favourites.
8/10
No comments:
Post a Comment